home baked and hand decorated
custom cutout cookies
Everyday Nazareth offers custom designed, home baked, and hand decorated cutout cookies. These are perfect for any kind of celebration - baptisms, weddings, birthdays, feast days, and more! Pickup in Middleton, WI.
Minimum order accepted is 2 dozen, full size cookies. Pricing starts at $45/dozen for vanilla bean cookies. Simple, mini cookies can be added for $20/dozen. Individual or custom packaging available. Base flavors offered year round include strawberry, lemon chia seed, white chocolate cranberry, and brandy old fashioned; seasonal or customized flavors available upon request.
start your custom cookie request.
If you’re interested in getting started on a cookie order, fill out the form to the right. We’ll get back to you within a day with more information and follow up questions.
Custom requests must be made at least two weeks in advance, but the more lead time the better!